60-unit hybrid boutique resort refinance
Project Summary
Refinance of a repositioned hospitality asset transformed from a legacy 25-unit roadside motel into a 60-unit hybrid resort combining lodge rooms, rustic cabins, modern cabins, tiny homes, and Airstream-style accommodations, with approximately $7.0 million already deployed by ownership since 2022. Rather than relying on borrower-provided historicals, the study built a market-supported underwriting framework: differentiated ADRs of $176–$248 by unit type producing a blended stabilized ADR of approximately $217, occupancy ramping from 57.0 percent to a stabilized 64.5 percent, and stabilized revenue of approximately $3.19 million with NOI of $1,147,623 after a 2.0 percent reserve allowance — a 36.0 percent margin.
What the Project Included
A mixed-format, experience-driven lodging platform positioned above traditional motels, competitive with boutique and short-term-rental supply, and below luxury resort pricing in a small, seasonal Northern California tourism market driven by Mount Shasta, river access, and outdoor recreation.
Capital Structure
$4,990,438 bank first mortgage at 8.100% over 300 months; $4,436,000 SBA debenture at 5.725% — total refinance debt of $9,426,438 with annual debt service of $800,260.
Feasibility Study Challenges
The study's defining task was distinguishing stabilized supportability from ramp-period risk — and stating both without softening. Projected coverage of 0.96x in Year 1 and 1.17x in Year 2 falls below the 1.25x lender-comfort threshold, so the study quantified the required interim DSCR reserve at $295,827 ($235,666 Year 1; $60,161 Year 2) rather than adjusting assumptions to make the problem disappear. When SBA-related review requested a coverage case excluding the twelve Airstream units, the addendum recomputed the deal on a 48-unit basis — stabilized DSCR of 1.16x, below threshold through Year 6 — and concluded plainly that the no-Airstream case is not supportable on the original stabilized basis without additional structural credit support or reduced leverage. The determination was narrowed, not revised, under underwriting pressure.