17-story, 184,960 SF office tower repositioning — ten-scenario highest and best use analysis
Project Summary
Repositioning analysis of a vacant 17-story, 184,960-square-foot tower in Durham, North Carolina — a full highest and best use study built around ten redevelopment scenarios spanning market-rate apartments, condominium sell-out, medical and life-sciences conversion, mixed-use, upper-upscale hotel, senior living, demolition with land resale, and continuation as Class A office. Each scenario was modeled through discounted cash flow with IRR, MIRR, XIRR, DSCR, ROE, and residual land value calculations, then ranked on capitalized value, land residual, debt capacity, and risk.
What the Project Included
The comparative grid put hard numbers against every path: market-rate apartments at $95,000,000 total project cost producing $121,000,000 of capitalized value and a 13.90 percent IRR; condominium sell-out at a 14.10 percent IRR; an upper-upscale hotel generating the highest revenue but carrying $110,000,000 of cost; demolition and land resale at $22,000,000; and Class A office conversion at a negative ten percent IRR — the decisive evidence that continuation in office use is not the highest and best use in today’s leasing market.
Capital Structure
Each scenario was capitalized at approximately 65 percent loan-to-cost debt with the balance — 35 percent of total project cost — as sponsor equity, with hard costs, soft costs, sales and lease-up costs, and entrepreneurial profit expectations carried separately so that the residual land value under each program could be compared on a consistent basis.
Feasibility Study Challenges
The analytical problem was discipline against wishful thinking: a highly visible tower invites every reuse idea, and the study’s job was to eliminate most of them. Heavy commercial allocations and all-large-unit residential mixes drove land residuals to breakeven or below; the hotel scenario carried the largest absolute cost and flag-related lease-up expense; and the office-continuation case, far from supporting any land value, produced a negative residual in the prevailing leasing market. The concluded apartment-anchored program won on the combination of land residual, financeability, and risk diversification rather than on any single headline figure.